An Approach to Evaluation and Benchmark Testing of Cartographic Data Production Systems

The Battelle Columbus Laboratories has developed an approach to evaluating state-of-the-art automated cartographic data/ map production systems. Evaluation is performed within the framework of an analog-to-vector (A/V) conversion model, which encompasses the overall cartographic data production process (i.e., source preparation, digitization, feature tagging, spatial coding, and data management). Attention is focused on the unique characteristics of cartographic manu scripts and the limitations of data capture systems. It also addresses editing functions, process speed, procedural trade-offs and production bottlenecks. These are all ana lyzed in the context of pertinent organizational require ments. A set of benchmark testing materials and procedures have been developed to assist in the evaluation of A/V systems. The paper discusses the A/V conversion model and the development of the benchmark testing package and